Contemporary conditions of critique: power, value(s), economy

Kristin Asdal co-organized a ph.d-course on critique and anti-critique with Nina Boy, at the Peace Research Institute of Oslo (PRIO).

Fabian Muniesa gave a talk on performativity and critique at the ph.d-course. (Photo: Kristin Asdal)

Course description

​In modern thought, critique is invoked as a particular relation to power: critique stands for the empowerment of the enlightened subject holding power to account, a premise continued by the tradition of capitalist critique. Over the last decades, performativity and ANT have emerged as influential alternatives to critique, alleging the modern critic to perform a self-defeating empowerment of the object of contestation. By some, these have been experienced as liberation from the foreclosed accusation of anti-capitalism, allowing for change in the small and concrete. Others have accused these of an unwitting alliance with capitalism, and the financial crisis in particular has renewed the prominence of capitalism in theorising and critiquing contemporary relations of power and inequality.

Against the backdrop of the cross-disciplinary debate between critique and anticritique, the course will discuss important contemporary phenomena, such as the changing value of knowledge from an end in itself to a means to societal or economic impact; the crisis in the measure of value and disappearance of traditional grounds of critique associated with contemporary finance; the declining value of evidence in the so-called post-factual reality; and the politicisation of values as normative foundation of critique.

Lectures

  • Introduction (Kristin Asdal and Nina Boy)
  • Critique of power and power of critique (Nina Boy)
  • Critique of value and value of critique (Brett Christophers)
  • Valuation and critique (Kristin Asdal)
  • Security, critique and normative orders (Kristoffer Liden)
  • Performance and critique (Angus Cameron)
  • Performativity and critique (Fabian Muniesa)

 

The course description was first published at PRIO's webpage. For more information about the course, visit PRIO.org.

Tags: Capitalism, Value, Critique, Actor-Network Theory, Power
Published Nov. 15, 2017 1:54 PM - Last modified Nov. 22, 2017 10:49 AM